SqWALK! Logo  
Port Alberni Aluminum Smelter

On this page

News and Recent Items
Aluminum Smelter for Port Alberni
Opinion
Links and Documents
Aluminum Price History
Contacts and More Information

News and Recent Items

Alberni Valley Aluminum Project
Alberni-Clayoquot Economic Development Commission project website
Executive Summary

Aluminum smelter findings are favourable
August, 2001
KTD of Spokane, Washington, has completed their pre-feasibility study to build a $1.5 billion aluminium smelter in the Alberni Valley, and its findings are - no surprise - favourable. The executive summary concludes Port Alberni is a "good site for a smelter because of its geographic location on the Pacific Rim in a country with zero political risk" The $1.5 billion project could employ 2,000 construction workers during a three-year period, and as many as 650 employees when it is up and running. The smelter could produce 360,000 tonnes of aluminium a year. David Krakoff, a KTD principal, says it's now a question of finding investors for the project.
Business Examiner, August, 2001 ... link
Alberni Valley Aluminum Project ...project details

Spokane group eyes aluminum venture
John Stucke, Spokesman-Review, Nov 16, 2000
Industry has history of low feasibility
Rene Chalifour, Alberni Valley Times, Nov 16, 2000
Smelter company new to game
Graham Andrews, Alberni Valley Times, Nov 16, 2000
Port Alberni pins hopes on smelter
Susan Danard, Times Colonist, Nov 16, 2000
Smelter Study on Vancouver Island
CBC News, Nov 15, 2000

TOP

Aluminum Smelter for Port Alberni

Then Premier Ujjal Dosanjh came to Port Alberni on November 15, 2000 to announce a pre-feasibility study for an aluminum smelter to be located just south of town. The full "pre-feasibility" study will cost about $1.3 million.  Of the $937 budgeted to August 31, 2001, the City of Port Alberni is in for $200,000, the Alberni-Clayoquot Regional District ($200K), the Port Alberni Regional Port Authority ($300K), HRDC ($77K), the Province of BC ($88K), and the federal government ($57K) Economic Development Commission. That's a lot of taxpayer money foolishly wasted on some Spokane opportunists.

The company proposing the project is KTD LLC of Spokane, Washington.  David Krakoff is the president of KTD.  After Krakoff and the other principles in KTD were freed up as part of a restructuring exercise at Kaiser Aluminum in Spokane, they briefly reconstituted themselves as KAI Technology, then emerged as KTD.  It is a company without a history, without a track record, without capital, and without work.  Good thing for them that Port Alberni was there when they needed a project.

The CBC news release at the time called this "a pre-feasibility study on the possibility of building an aluminum smelter."  This study is a make-work project for KTD, and at the time of its announcement, was a "make votes" exercise for both provincial and federal candidates.

In the context of BC Hydro and power generation, aluminum smelters require awesome amounts of electricity.  The project proposed for Port Alberni, 650 MW would be needed.  None of BC Hydro's planning includes a scenario for power supply on this scale for new industrial purposes.  PAGP was not being proposed with an aluminum smelter in mind, but the issue must not be forgotton.

The natural gas electricity strategy and aluminum smelters were both Glen Clark visions.  Gordon Campbell appears to want to continue with these absurd projects.

There is a lot of idled aluminum smelting capacity in the world.  The price of electricity and the price of aluminum are meeting at a point where making aluminum is not cost-justified.  Smelting operations with big electricity contracts are finding it more profitable to sell that electricity, than to make aluminum. 

Communities hard hit for revenue and jobs are such easy marks for opportunists, however - whether they are politicians looking for easy votes, or redundant aluminum executives looking for easy work.  The only jobs that Port Alberni is likely to see will be con jobs and a lot of hype.

Low priced electricity for industry was the carrot that Glen Clark dangled to smelter builders.  "Power for Jobs" he called it.  What sort of operating loss would Hydro have to carry if they were forced to sell this power to an aluminum smelter at the Clark smelter discount?  The Alberni-Clayoquot project website says "Preliminary indications have been given by the B.C. government that adequate power will be provided at competitive rates."

The feasibility study is complete, as of August 2001, and (no surprise) Port Alberni is the lucky winnah!  The executive summary concludes Port Alberni is a "good site for a smelter because of its geographic location on the Pacific Rim in a country with zero political risk." The only thing needed now, is power, and investors. Executive Summary

TOP

Opinion
November 16, 2000

You May Already Have Won An Aluminum Smelter Nov 16, 2000
Uncalled for parody ...more

An Aluminum Smelter? On Vancouver Island? Nov 16, 2000
Vaughn Palmer in the Vancouver Sun calls it a proposed boondoggle...more

Emperor Dosanjh Parades His New Clothes Nov 18, 2000
Uncalled for opinion from the SqWALK! editorial board...more

TOP

Links and Documents
November 13, 2000

Alberni Valley Aluminum Project
Alberni-Clayoquot Economic Development Commission

Bechtel/Alcan Alma Quebec Smelter Project
This project is owned by Alcan, and was built by Bechtel as chief contractor/consultant on the job. The Alma smelter appears very similar to the one being pitched for Port Alberni.
http://www.sqwalk.com/DEVOIR_19980518.htm
http://www.bechtel.com/whatnew/becProjs.html
http://www.bechtel.com/pdf/brief0699.pdf

About Aluminum Smelting
The World Aluminum Organization has lots of information about aluminum - from bauxite ore to the pop can. Check out the site at http://www.world-aluminium.org/

Aluminum prices to Oct 1, 2002

TOP

Contacts and More Information
November 16, 2000

Alberni Environmental Coalition
Write or fax (250) 723-4666
Email Office Co-ordinator Maureen Sager

Comments? Do you have information to share?
Smelter Line at SqWALK!

For more information, MLA addresses, etc: Contacts

TOP